Beitrag von Ann Handley

Profil von Ann Handley anzeigen, Grafik
Ann Handley Ann Handley ist Influencer:in

Digital marketing & content expert. Wall Street Journal bestselling author. Keynote speaker. Writer.

Woof. This quote hurts my heart. The value of great Content & Writing has often been misunderstood. But the attitude towards AI adoption suggested by this piece — “For many companies, the cost-cutting is worth a drop in quality.” — is more than tragic… it’s downright irresponsible and whacked. Because what’s “quality” mean, anyway? “Quality” means trustworthy, inspired, customer-obsessed empathetic content. It means content we’ve crafted that could come only from us. Or said another way: Quality content = empathy x useful x inspired “Drop in quality” = unremarkable, boring, me-too marketing “Drop in quality” = commodity content “Drop in quality” = a mudslide like erosion of customer trust Oof. (And don’t even get my going on “churning out” content from that quote.) Listen! I’m a fan of AI tools. They are useful tools. But sweet Cheez-Its… blindly implementing them with zero long-term, broader consequences is nuts. It’s a recipe for the nuttiest Nutloaf Disaster. * * * Right now, we talk about AI as just a Marketing or Content issue. But that’s changing. News that generative AI capabilities will within a few months be embedded in tools we use every day from Microsoft and Google and the like — means that how we write everything from emails to legal briefs will change. For worse (but I hope) for the better. (I’m an optimist.) Maybe one way to think about this is not be like that company… the “good enough” companies firing the writers, happy to watch customer trust slip into the sea. Maybe a better way is to thoughtfully implement AI tools to benefit not just the business… but our ***customers***. Remember them? 😉

  • Kein Alt-Text für dieses Bild vorhanden
Ann Handley

Digital marketing & content expert. Wall Street Journal bestselling author. Keynote speaker. Writer.

11 Monate

Probably should’ve dropped the link here earlier whoops. Side note: Some days…. I’d love to be a dog walker. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/06/02/ai-taking-jobs/

Drew Neisser

CEO @ CMO Huddles | Podcast host for B2B CMOs | Leading CMO Coach | AdAge CMO columnist | author Renegade Marketing | Inspiring B2B greatness via Community, Coaching + Content | Ben Franklin nut

11 Monate

Me too Ann Handley! We’re running a sizable man vs bot and a man & bot vs bot-alone copy test this summer. Primary measure will be SEO but will also look for anecdotal evidence that bot alone is more problematic than people realize. Hopefully the results will be worth sharing.

Drew Neisser

CEO @ CMO Huddles | Podcast host for B2B CMOs | Leading CMO Coach | AdAge CMO columnist | author Renegade Marketing | Inspiring B2B greatness via Community, Coaching + Content | Ben Franklin nut

7 Monate

Hi Ann Handley - We just published our Man v Machine content test and the good news is that humans prevailed over bots when it comes to creating content that drives search rankings, website traffic and readership. Here's a link to the study: https://cmohuddles.com/man-vs-machine-content-report If we were to do another test, I'd like to compare human-only to human IP with bot assistance. I suspect the results would be a lot closer, the quality of the content would be almost equal and the creation time would be 50% faster. Will be interested in your takeaways from the study. Michael Brenner - I know you feel differently so feel free to weigh in here. #GenAI #HumanMade #Marketing

Lav Crnobrnja

Co-founder at Vacation Tracker, Cloud Horizon and Knowlo

11 Monate

"AI doesn't match the writing skills of a human: It lacks personal voice and style" The first iPhone didn't have a front facing camera, had a crappy rear camera, and didn't even have GPS or any apps. Fast forward 10 years. While I would like to believe that we humans have a unique writing style and voice that cannot be reproduced by AI, I have a hard time seeing how AI does not surpass humans in terms of writing output quality over the next 10 years. I hope I'm wrong.

Kimberly D. Houston

Health & Ecommerce Copywriter | Healthcare, HealthTech, FemTech, Health & Wellness + Ecommerce | Copy & content that helps you stand out online and connect with your ideal audience

11 Monate

“For many companies, the cost-cutting is worth a drop in quality.”  <-- You hate to see it. Months ago, someone on LinkedIn said that many companies that use content require only that it be "serviceable," and for those businesses, AI is going to be a godsend, and goodbye, content writers we used to employ. Guess that's turned out to be true. I love what John Warner said in his newsletter this morning: "What is upsetting about so much of the commentary and hype around ChatGPT is that it ignores the fact of writing and reading as experiences. To some, as long as ChatGPT generates content that is plausible, passing a (very) surface-level muster, we should be impressed and allow it to substitute for the human-produced text."

Rowan Elizabeth

Rewild your brand. Reclaim your story.

11 Monate

Screw "content". I am a writer. I carefully craft. I don't spew forth filler. I don't get paid for generating words. I get paid for assembling words in an order that nobody else could. AI can kiss my ass. I don't need help with my creativity. I'm a goddam creative.

Treasa Edmond

Content Strategist & Manager • Ghostwriter • Podcast Host • Helping freelancers and businesses grow their business with intentional content, strategy & client management and communication.

11 Monate

A company that puts eeking out every penny ahead of customer relationships is not a company with a long future. Even if they realized and truly understood that content helps build that relationship, it wouldn’t matter. The companies that focus on their customer will always need writers. In some ways, it’s good for writers. The “user” clients who pay low rates, are toxic AF, and who don’t appreciate content are choosing AI. The high-value, appreciative clients will need more writers.

Annie Zelm

Content Department Director at Kuno Creative

11 Monate

It’s a good reminder to all of us not to let our identity become too dependent on any one skill or job title. I used to see myself as a writer, but I knew I’d have to find more practical ways to make money until I could figure out how to write and publish books that would sell. In my 20s, I saw myself as a journalist until that role became less valued. So I pivoted to “marketing manager” and then “brand journalist.” Now as a content director who works with clients in many different industries, I still believe in content marketing, but I see myself more as a marketing strategist, mentor, editor, researcher, branding consultant, website copywriter, SEO writer, email marketer, and sales rep/business owner now that our company is employee-owned and someone who will probably always write to share my perspective whether or not I’m making money from it. More importantly, I want my identity to reflect my values and how I show up for the people I’m in a position to help, no matter what that looks like. There are going to be difficult transitions ahead for all of us. But if we focus on creating value, learning and being adaptable, we still have a lot of reasons to be hopeful.

Kathy Casciani

I help emerging services businesses get started with PR

11 Monate

Yes yes yes - every bit of this. Just say no to commodity content! And by the way, could AI come up with “sweet Cheez-It’s”? Nope!

Bill Honnold, CCM

I Provide Busy, Aspiring Construction Managers With Convenient, Affordable Online Training To Accelerate Their Career And Earn More Money

11 Monate

As writers, I think we need to learn how to use whatever tools help us improve our quality and simplify our jobs. For example, I love carpentry. And there are constant improvements in how to build things. Better joinery. Safety improvements. I learn about which tools can help me build better projects and ignore the rest. The same applies to AI. Give it a try. See what helps your writing. Discard the rest. Companies that churn out crappy content will eventually loose readers because their writing will become a commodity. Humans connect emotionally with other humans, not machines. No machine or AI can tell my story like I can. So, I don’t worry. I try to stay ahead of the power curve. PS - This comment was written by a human and not AI.

Weitere Kommentare anzeigen

Loggen Sie sich ein, um Kommentare zu sehen oder hinzuzufügen.